Are PVC Toys Safe for Children?
Phthalate Update 11/1/99:
C. Everett Koop, former
U.S. Surgeon General, has been called
"America's Doctor". He was senior author of a review of the
literature on DEHP & DINP, phthalates used respectively in Medical
products and soft toys (including teethers), published June 22, 1999. The paper's conclusion?
Phthalates in PVC are safe for consumers, although more study is recommended.
The recommendation of further study is repeated several times in the
document, although the popular press often simply reported the
findings as "Koop declares vinyl safe!". The reporting has
even referred to the group as the "Koop Commission", suggesting
that this is somehow a official Federal undertaking. In fact, it was
funded by a private organization to which Koop had close ties, funded by,
among other sources, donations from many private corporations.
PVC, or Polyvinyl Chloride (Vinyl), is one of the materials most commonly used
for
children's toys, and in fact, for so much of the things with which we surround ourselves:
car trim and interiors, household water pipes, packaging (including food packaging), house
siding, all sorts of medical and surgical devices, clothing, and children's products, including toys.
. There is a growing concern about
some of the components of PVC, which may present a very serious hazard to children.
During 1999, a growing list of mass-market manufacturers have announce that
they are seeking alternatives to the use of PVC, including Nike, many
toy companies, and Ford Motor Co. In this large and expanding section of the turnertoys.com website, we
examine these
questions in great detail. We present here the nature of the hazard, responses from
the plastics and chemical industry spokespeople, and our own analysis, in an effort to
sort out the arguments. To get full value
from these pages, you should plan to spend a fair amount of time browsing
the pages. We have prepared a new "print-friendly" version,
which allows you to print the main parts of the report, read off-line, and
return to read the supplementary documents when you have time